Verified
YES

Macy Dubois Office Building On Charles Street Being Demolished for Condo

  • Incident Incident
  • Nearby Incident Nearby Incident

Incident Report Description

The City of Toronto has a bad name in terms of preservation - it's undeniable. But it's questionable of why the city still allows important architecture to be demolished, listed on the inventory of heritage properties or not.

An office building located on 45 Charles Street is to be demolished for a condominium, replacing our few surviving examples of modernist architecture, and works by the architect.

45 Charles was designed by the late Macy Dubois, who was an essential architect in Toronto's second urban renewal during the 1960s and 70s, when concrete architecture became a popular material. The building received much praise for it's angular form, even from Progressive Architecture magazine in its' August 1967 issue.

Dubois moved to Toronto after competing in the architectural competition for a new city hall in Toronto. During his career as an architect in the city, he went on to win two Massey Medals, Low Energy Building Design Award of Excellence, Governor General's Medal in Architecture, and Toronto Historical Board Award of Merit.

Macy Dubois is undoubtedly an important architect to Toronto. His concrete designs were critically acclaimed everywhere. His projects include the Central Tech High School Arts Centre (which received praise from, and a feature in The New York Times), New College, Oxford University Press, Canadian Embassy in Beijing, Toronto Emergency Services headquarters, and the Ontario Pavilion at Montreal's Expo '67. He also started two architectural firms in Toronto. His work extended to designing buildings for many southern Ontario schools, including Lakehead University, Trent University, and Ontario Police College.

The time at which Modernism in architecture was popular, Toronto also erected many examples, making this era an essential time for the city, in which it brought in architects from around the world. These architects made iconic structures in Toronto's skyline, like Mies van der Rohe's TD Centre and Viljo Revell's New City Hall.

Toronto has a history of demolishing beautiful modernist architecture, for example, the Shell Oil Tower and other buildings at the CNE.

And now, a condo developer has been granted permission to destroy Dubois' building, and replace it with a glass and metal condo that goes as far as to mimic the design, from the angles at the balconies, right down to the blocks at the top.

45 Charles is, without a doubt, a heritage site and a most valuable building to Toronto, not just for modernist architecture. Macy DuBois is a missed and highly respected architect, and it would be a crime allow one of his buildings to be erased from the city's history.
Credibility: UP  DOWN  0
ADDITIONAL REPORTS AND DISCUSSION   (Add)

Gordon Zimmerman (Feb 2 2011)

You could add the federal government building at 4900 Yonge Street to the list of significant Macy DuBois designs. Also, the impact of the Charles Street building being published in the Progressive Architecture periodical was important and probably influenced choosing him to design 4900 and probably others.

Credibility:  UP  DOWN 
0

Lolly (Jul 3 2011)

I’m not wohrty to be in the same forum. ROTFL

Credibility:  UP  DOWN 
0

Lolly (Jul 3 2011)

I’m not wohrty to be in the same forum. ROTFL

Credibility:  UP  DOWN 
0

Images

Incident Report(s)

TITLE LOCATION DATE
204 Beech Avenue: Why we need heritage conservation districts204 beech ave. toronto ONJun 2 2010
Colborne Street: 41 historic buildings could be razedcolborne street brantfordJun 5 2010
Ontario Heritage Center is a Hidden Gem in the City of Toronto8 & 10 Adelaide St. E, Toronto, OntarioJun 7 2010
Wonderful old double-decker theater beautifully restored.189 Yonge St. Toronto, OntarioJun 7 2010
Amazing example of adaptive re-use of industrial architecture401 Wellington Street West, TorontoJun 7 2010

Name:
E-Mail:
Comments:
Security Code:
Captcha